There’s something I’ve tried explaining in recent years a bit more to people I know.
I picked up some fantasy novels in an effort to use up an Amazon gift card. Because of True Dungeon, I became aware of Patrick Rothfuss’s The Kingkiller Chronicle. It occurs to me those two sentences would logically be switched in order, but, if you read my blog, you may grasp that I don’t always follow logical order.
I finished the first book last week and am a bit more than 750 pages into the second book.
I got into something of a discussion Thursday with the Shadowfist group, mostly around my view that the series purposefully endeavors to merge low fantasy and high fantasy.
And, so, the usual trying to explain what low fantasy is and what high fantasy is. I was a bit surprised anyone would think Lord of the Rings wasn’t high fantasy. To me, it’s a classic and illustrative example.
While it’s hard for me to argue against high magic being prevalent in high fantasy, there’s more to it than that. D&D is not philosophically high fantasy. It’s videogame fantasy. You obsess over power, whether through stuff or levels. You hope some random wheel of fate gives you +5 Strength.
But, I’ve said as much before.
I’m quite enjoying the series. In fact, it’s addictive.
Movies aren’t. TV can be. I’ve said as much before, but let me try it a different way.
Movies are complete. They are straightforward. They are bombastic. TV has more opportunities to twist and turn as there’s so much more content, and they are often incomplete. At least, for me, they are incomplete, as I often don’t pay much attention to series when they end. The threat of ending is why I am so reluctant to invest in series that sound interesting.
Books are different.
When I was in sixth grade, the teacher brought a box of books, put them in the side room (storage?, was there a sink?). The box was full of fantasy and science fiction novels. She was giving them away. The other students may have taken more than I thought, but I remember only a casual interest.
I took an armful, a stack.
I may have read some of those books – I believe a few. I’m fairly sure I didn’t read some. I’m fairly sure I still own them and could read them at my leisure.
What have I been trying to explain?
I have an affinity to the Kingkiller Chronicle. Oh, I don’t think highly of my abilities. I found myself increasingly weary of the obsession over low fantasy concerns, like paying tuition or going hungry. I don’t embrace entertainment for real world concerns. I embrace entertainment for adventure, for drama, for melodrama, for another world.
I have fantasy novels that I have no affinity for. Perhaps I didn’t read long enough. But, my way of explanation for giving up on them is that they throw too many fantasy names of people and places at me too soon without my caring a jot about the characters or the plot.
I have some … criticisms isn’t the right word because writing is hard and different people have different tastes … hindrances to elevating the series to some lofty perch.
I said an addiction. Books do that to me, even ones that aren’t so great. I’ve read a good number of Xanth books, and they become much more childish over time. One of those books I read when on vacation with family in Honolulu. A day or maybe one and a half.
An addiction because stories do more then tell stories. They inspire other stories.
RPG play is more like TV to me. I don’t mean RPG campaign ideas or whatever, I mean the actual play. The actual play lives beyond itself to a degree but not the same degree. It’s too much one thing. The value in the long running campaigns, with the PC development, is that they expand beyond one thing. I still think of Usagi Kidai beyond the Princess Police. Ty maybe not as much, anymore, but Ty and Rald and Hak and Smed and so on.
But, books, they inspire me to riff.
Being incompetent with music besides knowing what’s good, bad, and interesting better than anyone else who has ever lived, I imagine that musicians feel that way with music. They want to riff.
I will stop reading. I will peer into that other world and I will construct my own story. The characters may be much the same or the scene may be much the same or the concept may be much the same. Sometimes, it’s an idea for a novel but usually it’s dialogue. I so love dialogue.
Eventually, I will return to reading.
The more I riff, the more entertainment I will get from a book. Even bad books, which is why I continued with bad series long after they stopped being decent series. I’ll forego naming names, as I can respect those who have abilities beyond my own.
I’ve been riffing a lot more with this series than I have in a long, long time.
I’m starting to remember something, something important, but that’s either going to sound ridiculous, pretentious, or will not elicit enough reaction to bother. People don’t listen to me, but it’s not my job to force them.
I suppose one piece of that, though, may sound not so ridiculous. I perceive the world differently at the moment. Sure, Star Wars movies can do that, too, and music does that, and so can other things. The mind is rather malleable when you let it be.
I have his children’s(?) book to read after day two. I have a series my sister had on her Christmas list that I decided to try out for myself afterwards.
So many distractions. So much time.